A tenant moving out, or a change of commercial tenant, always means organisational work for property managers. It gets critical when the handover reveals that one of the keys is missing. The question then comes up fast: who is liable for the damage, and does the building's entire locking system have to be replaced at the former tenant's expense?
The legal situation described here is German law. In this article we sum up what Germany's Federal Court of Justice has decided and share four lessons on how property managers keep the liability risk small with complete records.
When does a tenant have to pay for a new locking system?
Only under three conditions. A lost key does not automatically mean the tenant pays for replacing the whole locking system. In its ruling of 5 March 2014 (case VIII ZR 205/13), the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) set out clear requirements:
| Requirement | What it means |
|---|---|
| Tenant at fault | The tenant is only liable if they are at fault for the loss, for example through negligence. If the key was stolen despite being kept carefully, liability often falls away. |
| Concrete risk of misuse | The replacement has to be necessary for security reasons: there is a real risk that unauthorised people link the key to the building and use it, for example because it was lost together with an address or name tag. |
| Actual replacement | Damages are only due once the locking system has really been replaced. A notional claim based on a quote is not enough. |
For the property manager this means that whether there is a claim depends on facts they have to prove. Which keys were handed out, when and to whom? And how concrete is the risk? That is where the following lessons come in. This article is not legal advice; clarify liability in each case with your legal adviser.
Why do the records at move-in decide the claim?
Because a claim is only as strong as the proof that all keys were handed over. If a key is missing at the handover, the guesswork over paper records often begins: were there three keys or four? Which numbers? If it is one word against another, the property manager is in the weakest position.
With Log+Key you record the number of keys and their key numbers digitally at move-in and move-out. The tenant is added as a contact and assigned the keys, and the receipt goes to them by email. For the handover report itself there is our free template Key handover at move-in and move-out.
How do keys disappear during vacancies and refurbishments?
Usually without anyone noticing. Not every lost key goes back to a tenant: keys often disappear while a flat stands empty or is being refurbished, when tradespeople, estate agents or cleaning firms get access.
With Log+Key you hand keys to external service providers with a return date. Once it has passed, the person holding the key gets an email, and the office too if you wish. That way keys do not stay in circulation unnoticed for weeks.
How does the property manager assess the risk of misuse quickly?
By seeing straight away which key is missing and what it opens. When a key is lost, the property manager has to clarify whether there is a concrete risk of misuse. A key lost on holiday is a different matter from one lost right outside the front door.
The Log+Key history shows who got the key when and when it last moved. Which doors and shared rooms it opens is in the master key plan. Together they allow a realistic assessment instead of rushed panic.
What does the property manager need to keep costs back from the deposit?
A case that is traceable and fully documented. If the property manager wants to keep the cost of replacement keys or a new locking system back from the deposit, they have to be able to show what was handed out and what came back.
In Log+Key you search the history for the key or the flat and export the entries as CSV, with date, recipient, comment and signature. That puts every step in one place for the insurer or legal adviser.
Step by step: when a key is missing at the flat handover
- Note in the handover report which key is missing, with its number and type (flat, front door, cellar, letterbox).
- Check the history for when and to whom the key was handed out.
- Clarify with the tenant where and how the key was lost: that decides the risk of misuse.
- Look up the master key plan to see which doors the key opens, and decide whether a replacement key is enough or cylinders have to be changed.
- Document the case and have liability checked legally before you claim any costs.
Read more about what property managers experience with keys day to day in What property management firms taught us about key handovers. How Log+Key works for property managers is on the page Key management for property managers; for an overview of all features see key management software.
Would you like to see how Log+Key supports your property management with key records? Book a free demo, or try Log+Key for free with up to 10 keys or items.
